This is not the final list, but before I finalize it tomorrow night - I wanted to make sure I didn't miss anything egregious. Again, doing a lot of this from memory. Any additional nominees, please just reply or message me.
And if you're not on there when you feel you should, please don't read into it anymore than my memory failing me when a lot has happened in the last 18 months.
Male Wrestler of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Asher Hayes
- Cid Turner
- Dexter Grant
- Gavin Taylor
- Giovanni Aries
- James Evans
- Xander Valentine
- Waylon Creek
Female Wrestler of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Amelia Nevado
- Colleen MacDonald
- Deanna Frost
- The Glimmer Sisters
- Glory Braddock
- Kimberly Williams
- La Pequena Luz
- Meghan Strader
- Polly Playtime
- Selena Frost
- Syren
Tag Team of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- The Connection
- The European Fiery Nation
- Fall of Man
- The Glimmer Sisters
- Hollywood
- Light in the Darkness
- The Product
- Selena Frost & Xander Valentine
- The Shinigami Foundation
- The Vision
Match of the year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Waylon Creek vs. Xander Valentine – Retribution 2025
- Xander Valentine vs. Giovanni Aries vs. Waylon Creek vs. James Evans – Taking Hold of the Flame 2025
- Konrad Raab vs. Colleen MacDonald vs. Drake Hemingway vs. Tommy Valentine vs. Kimberly Williams vs. Xander Valentine – Under Attack 2025
- Clyde Sutter, Melinda Braddock & Alex Belmont vs. James Evans, Enigma, & Gina Glimmer - 2025 Trios Tournament Finals, Under Attack 2025
- Glory Braddock vs. Amelia Nevado – Shattered Reality: Night Two 2025
- James Evans vs. Cid Turner – Shattered Reality: Night Two 2025
- La Pequena Luz vs. Clyde Sutter – Breakdown, Fatal Fortunes, 2026
- Underground Championship Turmoil – Breakdown, 2026
- Meghan Strader vs. La Pequena Luz – Retribution 2026
- Selena Frost vs. Syren vs. Amelia Nevado vs. Gavin Taylor – Hubris 2026
- The Glimmer Sisters vs. The Light in the Darkness – Taking Hold of the Flame 2026
Feud/Story of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Amelia Nevado’s fight to finally break through to main event status
- Chris Dumont vs. Gavin Taylor
- Dexter Grant vs. Kimberly Williams
- The Fall of Man vs. Xander Valentine
- Gavin Taylor’s rise to Make SCW Gavin Again
- Jordan Majors vs. Asher Hayes
- Kimberly Williams vs. Colleen MacDonald
- La Pequena Luz vs. Meghan Strader
- Meghan Strader vs. Syren
- Selena Frost & Xander Valentine vs. The Glimmer Sisters
- Selena Frost and her quest for the World Title
- Syren vs. Gavin Taylor
Shocking Moment of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Amelia Nevado aligns with Frank Delatosso to get her World Title shot
- Cid Turner returns at Taking Hold of the Flame 2025 and wins alongside Xander Valentine
- Dexter Grant wins the fan vote and defeats Meghan Strader to become US Champion
- Gavin Taylor wins the SCW World Championship
- The Glimmer Sisters attack Selena Frost
- Giovanni Aries wins the World Championship at Taking Hold of the Flame 2026
- Jordan Majors’s elaborate plan of revenge against Asher Hayes
- Kandis and Tommy Valentine return at Retribution 2025
- Polly Playtime attacks CHBK in a steel cage
- Selena Frost steals Deanna Frost’s World Title Shot to muscle into Hubris
- Shaun Cruze returns from retirement
- Simon Lyman reveals his health issues and impending retirement
SCW Rookie of the Year (best first year in SCW) (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Damon Cage
- ENIGMA
- Federico Gasperoni
- Jackson Mikaelson
- Just Some Loser
- Kemal Yilmaz
- Meghan Strader
- Oskar Theron
- Scarlett Carsons
SCW Star of Tomorrow (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Brittany Williams
- Chris Dumont
- Colleen MacDonald
- Crystal Zdunich
- David Belmont
- David Striker
- Dexter Grant
- Kemal Yilmaz
- Kirsten Scott
- Marquis Dawson
- Scarlett Carsons
- Soren Cross
- Xavier Holloway
And if you're not on there when you feel you should, please don't read into it anymore than my memory failing me when a lot has happened in the last 18 months.
Male Wrestler of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Asher Hayes
- Cid Turner
- Dexter Grant
- Gavin Taylor
- Giovanni Aries
- James Evans
- Xander Valentine
- Waylon Creek
Female Wrestler of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Amelia Nevado
- Colleen MacDonald
- Deanna Frost
- The Glimmer Sisters
- Glory Braddock
- Kimberly Williams
- La Pequena Luz
- Meghan Strader
- Polly Playtime
- Selena Frost
- Syren
Tag Team of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- The Connection
- The European Fiery Nation
- Fall of Man
- The Glimmer Sisters
- Hollywood
- Light in the Darkness
- The Product
- Selena Frost & Xander Valentine
- The Shinigami Foundation
- The Vision
Match of the year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Waylon Creek vs. Xander Valentine – Retribution 2025
- Xander Valentine vs. Giovanni Aries vs. Waylon Creek vs. James Evans – Taking Hold of the Flame 2025
- Konrad Raab vs. Colleen MacDonald vs. Drake Hemingway vs. Tommy Valentine vs. Kimberly Williams vs. Xander Valentine – Under Attack 2025
- Clyde Sutter, Melinda Braddock & Alex Belmont vs. James Evans, Enigma, & Gina Glimmer - 2025 Trios Tournament Finals, Under Attack 2025
- Glory Braddock vs. Amelia Nevado – Shattered Reality: Night Two 2025
- James Evans vs. Cid Turner – Shattered Reality: Night Two 2025
- La Pequena Luz vs. Clyde Sutter – Breakdown, Fatal Fortunes, 2026
- Underground Championship Turmoil – Breakdown, 2026
- Meghan Strader vs. La Pequena Luz – Retribution 2026
- Selena Frost vs. Syren vs. Amelia Nevado vs. Gavin Taylor – Hubris 2026
- The Glimmer Sisters vs. The Light in the Darkness – Taking Hold of the Flame 2026
Feud/Story of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Amelia Nevado’s fight to finally break through to main event status
- Chris Dumont vs. Gavin Taylor
- Dexter Grant vs. Kimberly Williams
- The Fall of Man vs. Xander Valentine
- Gavin Taylor’s rise to Make SCW Gavin Again
- Jordan Majors vs. Asher Hayes
- Kimberly Williams vs. Colleen MacDonald
- La Pequena Luz vs. Meghan Strader
- Meghan Strader vs. Syren
- Selena Frost & Xander Valentine vs. The Glimmer Sisters
- Selena Frost and her quest for the World Title
- Syren vs. Gavin Taylor
Shocking Moment of the Year (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Amelia Nevado aligns with Frank Delatosso to get her World Title shot
- Cid Turner returns at Taking Hold of the Flame 2025 and wins alongside Xander Valentine
- Dexter Grant wins the fan vote and defeats Meghan Strader to become US Champion
- Gavin Taylor wins the SCW World Championship
- The Glimmer Sisters attack Selena Frost
- Giovanni Aries wins the World Championship at Taking Hold of the Flame 2026
- Jordan Majors’s elaborate plan of revenge against Asher Hayes
- Kandis and Tommy Valentine return at Retribution 2025
- Polly Playtime attacks CHBK in a steel cage
- Selena Frost steals Deanna Frost’s World Title Shot to muscle into Hubris
- Shaun Cruze returns from retirement
- Simon Lyman reveals his health issues and impending retirement
SCW Rookie of the Year (best first year in SCW) (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Damon Cage
- ENIGMA
- Federico Gasperoni
- Jackson Mikaelson
- Just Some Loser
- Kemal Yilmaz
- Meghan Strader
- Oskar Theron
- Scarlett Carsons
SCW Star of Tomorrow (January 1, 2025 to July 31, 2026)
- Brittany Williams
- Chris Dumont
- Colleen MacDonald
- Crystal Zdunich
- David Belmont
- David Striker
- Dexter Grant
- Kemal Yilmaz
- Kirsten Scott
- Marquis Dawson
- Scarlett Carsons
- Soren Cross
- Xavier Holloway